The Negotiation and the Block

The week-long talks to define a negotiating mandate for an internationally legally binding treaty on the use of autonomous weapons failed shortly before 5 a.m. on Saturday morning, after overnight negotiations that did not overcome Russia's objections. This is reported by The Guardian, according to which the majority of states present at the UN Review Conference on Conventional Weapons in Geneva wanted a mandate for a binding treaty.

The forum operates by consensus: all 128 parties to the convention must agree in order to approve a declaration. The high threshold led the conference to adopt a much weaker option, a mandate that merely asks countries to “elaborate by consensus,” an instrument that, according to the source, might not entail any legal obligation.

Who Is Holding Back and Who Is Pushing

According to the newspaper's account, Russia led the objections with obstructive tactics from the very first day. But other states with heavy investments in military AI, such as the United States, were reluctant to commit to a binding protocol to protect civilians from robotic drones and other autonomous weapons. Some argued that international humanitarian law is sufficient.

More than 100 states were pushing for a new law, arguing that these weapons pose entirely new challenges. European and NATO states, including Ukraine, along with China and Iran, expressed support for or openness to a new protocol. South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the United Kingdom, France and Germany, among the defense technology powers exploring AI-enabled weapons, expressed resistance to legal constraints, preferring a non-binding agreement.

The United States said that the need for human control over autonomous weapons was discussed in meetings between President Xi Jinping and Donald Trump, but that it remains opposed to a binding treaty. Diplomats present said Russia was deliberately obstructing and was not acting in good faith, unlike the U.S. delegates, who were seeking a consensus declaration. The exclusion of some non-member countries from the negotiations prompted a rare protest in the chamber on the final day, with the Egyptian delegation challenging the conference president.

Reactions and context

Max Tegmark, president of the Future of Life Institute, said world leaders had failed to seize the moment: "Slaughterbots are already here," he said, adding that states had agreed that merely talking about them was enough for the fourteenth year. Bonnie Docherty, senior arms adviser at Human Rights Watch, told the Guardian that autonomous weapons require a binding law, noting that similar treaties can be negotiated in 15 months and rejecting the U.S. proposal for five years to define a mandate. A group of seven countries — Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama — had led the push for a binding treaty to be negotiated within a year.

The Brazilian delegate said in the chamber on Wednesday that these are not weapons of the future but are already in use and under further development, and that time is running late for regulating these systems. The source recalls that the conference has not approved new weapons laws in the past 30 years, pushing states toward alternative paths, such as the 2008 ban on cluster munitions. The material also cites John Bolton, former U.S. national security adviser, according to whom the world is approaching a war that is almost entirely unmanned.

The text finally reports that Israel and the United States used AI-enabled targeting systems for tens of thousands of strikes in Gaza and Iran, with massive casualties, and that the Pentagon reportedly struck more than 1,000 targets in Iran on the first day of the war, with the aim, according to investigative reports, of 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour.

Source and attribution: this original summary was prepared by AICronaca based on the report by The Guardian — AI ↗The statements are attributed to the source; possible information limitations: The material is based on a single article in The Guardian and does not indicate the exact text of the formula adopted or the number of countries that voted in favor. Bolton's statements and the data on the attacks cited are reported by the source without independent verification. It is unclear which non-member countries were excluded. The next negotiating step is not specified.