South Korea's crackdown and Mann's voice
South Korea has tightened controls on smart glasses ahead of the Suneung, the national university entrance exam, scheduled for Thursday. According to Ministry of Education rules reported by the Korea Herald, wearing or using these devices during the test cancels the candidate's result and bars them from taking the exam the following year. Those found in possession of the glasses after failing to hand them in before the first session similarly have their test invalidated.
In this context, Steve Mann, a professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Toronto and regarded as the father of wearable computing, told the South Korean newspaper that the problem is not the tool but the way assessments are designed. Mann, who built an embryonic version of smart glasses in 1978, explained that even then acquaintances asked him whether the device would help him in exams. Today his question is different: what should an exam measure?
The calculator analogy and the connectivity question
Mann compared smart glasses to calculators. He recalls that in his day using one during a test was considered cheating, but over time exams adapted to a tool that became part of everyday use. The same reasoning, in his view, applies to wearable devices: if a person uses them in daily life, assessment should reflect what they are able to do with them. And because technology replaces tasks once performed without aids, exams should reconsider which abilities they measure. An intelligence test, he said, must test real intelligence, not mere mechanical memorization.
Asked about glasses that provide answers during exams, Mann first asked whether the devices were connected to the internet. His point is that the problem concerns network access during the test and that limiting connectivity could help prevent fraudulent behavior. He also argued that those who depend on assistive technologies should be able to use during exams the devices they rely on in daily life, recalling that he has worn his own for 48 years and considers them part of his body, to the point of wearing them even in his passport photo.
Design, rights and open questions
On aesthetic grounds, Mann believes that the choice of whether the glasses should look different from ordinary ones should be up to the wearer. He stated that even temporary restrictions can violate a person's rights, arguing that a temporary suspension of rights is no more acceptable than a permanent one. People, he added, and particularly those with disabilities, should have the freedom to be as they are and to present themselves as they are.
Several points that the material does not resolve remain unclear. It does not indicate which specific checks will be carried out during the Suneung or how any internet connection of the devices will be verified. It is also not specified whether the South Korean authorities intend to revise the rules or the format of the exam, nor whether Mann's proposals have been taken up by the Ministry of Education. His positions should be read as the statements of an expert, not as policy decisions. The debate ultimately raises a question of fairness: distinguishing between the use of accessibility aids and access to information during the test, without the text clarifying how the two cases will be handled in practice.
