The workers’ request
According to an account reported by Bloomberg and amplified by IT之家 on November 20, more than 500 Google employees and contractors have signed a petition addressed to CEO Sundar Pichai, Head of Search Elizabeth Reid and Head of Education Chris Phillips. The initiative was promoted by the Alphabet Workers Union, which represents permanent employees, temporary workers, vendors and contractors of Alphabet, Google and YouTube.
The request is specific: allow primary and secondary schools to continue using Google Search without generative AI features. The signatories argue that denying this access to those who do not want AI would risk driving institutions away from the Google ecosystem, making it harder to win over users and pushing schools to abandon the company’s products altogether. This is an internal position, not a corporate decision.
The context of the contested decision
The petition comes after Google decided to expand the reach of AI services in schools, making Gemini accessible to many primary and secondary school students. The move has raised concerns among teachers, parents and policymakers, who worry that AI use could weaken students’ critical thinking and reduce independent information-seeking beyond automatically generated answers.
Google responded that it works closely with schools to ensure products are useful to students and teachers. The company said it understands concerns about those who use AI to take shortcuts in studying, adding that it shares the goal of helping students learn. To reduce fears, Google plans to disable AI features intended for students by default. According to the source material, however, schools that want to continue using Search may still have to accept the version with integrated AI.
The technical issue and internal positions
Google management believes that if it did not offer AI features to students, other companies could move first with potentially less responsible approaches. Some employees do not share this justification and raise a technical question: whether it is truly impossible to create a version of Search without generative AI.
The issue remains open. The source material does not indicate whether Google has granted an exemption, nor what the timeline or results of the petition are. It is also unclear whether the default disabling of AI features for students applies to all schools or only certain configurations. The actual arrangements for schools’ access to Search and the outcome of the internal discussion therefore remain to be verified.
