What changes in healthcare professionals' negligence

The bill on health professions and professional liability, approved by the Chamber of Deputies on 28 October 2026 and now under Senate examination as A.S. 2082, amends Article 590-sexies of the Criminal Code, which concerns negligent homicide and personal injury in healthcare. According to Agenda Digitale's reconstruction, the current text expressly cites incompetence among the grounds for non-punishability, whereas the new approach provides for punishability only for gross negligence when the professional follows guidelines or good practices appropriate to the specific case, without making the limitation contingent on incompetence.

The decisive point therefore becomes the choice of guidance to apply: a protocol unsuitable for the patient's condition, the source writes, would not guarantee the protection envisaged. The measure is not yet law and may be amended during parliamentary examination.

Working conditions enter the assessment

The new Article 590-septies would require the judge to assess negligence and its gravity by considering the conditions in which the professional operated, including organizational shortcomings that the healthcare professional could not avoid. The aim, according to the analysis, is to reconstruct what could reasonably be expected of the doctor without turning every difficulty in the service into a justification for error.

However, the question remains open of who should answer for those inefficiencies: if they contributed to the harm, the source observes, it must be established who should have prevented them. The distinction between the criminal and civil levels remains central, because the Gelli-Bianco law already provides for the contractual liability of the facility, and limiting the doctor's punishability does not in itself eliminate the right to compensation.

AI as support, liability to be clarified

Article 4 of the bill entrusts the Government with two tasks: define a strategy for the healthcare use of artificial intelligence in compliance with the AI Act and promote regional courses on digitalization. These are delegation criteria to be implemented through legislative decrees, which introduce neither a specific medical liability for AI nor a new allocation of responsibility among doctor, facility and supplier.

Article 3 includes in the delegation access to health data by professionals involved in the care pathway, with a requirement for authorizations proportionate to the work performed, tracking and controls. The source recalls that Law 132 of 2025 already considers AI a support tool and reserves the decision to the doctor: the professional's presence at the final step, it warns, is not enough to transfer to them every technological risk.

Source and attribution: this original summary was prepared by AICronaca based on the report by Agenda Digitale ↗. The statements are attributed to the source; any informational limitations: The measure is not yet law and may be amended in the Senate. The indications on AI are delegation criteria, not operative provisions; the material does not quantify costs, timelines or effects of litigation..